PALAESTRA: Forum Of Sport, Physical Education & Recreation For Those With Disabilities logo

SUMMER 2000
Volume 16

Number 3
Issued Quarterly

Articles featured in this issue:
PALAESTRA cover

Use of Physical Activity to Improve Behavior of Children with Autism -

Two for One Benefits
by John O'Connor, Ron French, and Hester Henderson

 

activity picture

    Physical activity is vital for a healthy lifestyle for children with and without disabilities (Huettig & O'Connor, 1999). Physical activity offers a variety of benefits for individuals with autism. Following moderate aerobic activity, children with autism may experience increases in attention span, on-task behavior, and level of correct responding (Rosenthal-Malek & Mitchell, 1997). A physical activity-based program is easy to implement and has been shown to be effective in controlling many types of inappropriate behaviors associated with autism (Allison, Basile, & MacDonald, 1991; Elliott, Dobbin, Rose, & Soper, 1994).
    Children with autism may experience initial difficulties in physical activity programs because of inability to cope with the variety of auditory, visual, and tactile stimuli in wide-open spaces (see Figure 1, click here). This inability to cope may be demonstrated by various behaviors, such as over sensitivity to stimuli (i.e., outbursts, pacing, hand flapping, toe walking); deficits in speech, language, and cognitive capacities; desire to avoid changes in routines; and difficulties transferring lessons from one setting to another.


Ron French
          
     Children with autism may also experience deficits in interpersonal relationships, not seeking or readily accepting affection, avoiding play with peers or participation in physical activities, and avoiding eye contact. Exhibiting self-stimulatory or stereotypic behaviors, or being unable to relate normally to other people and situations are also typical of young children with autism (American Psychiatric Association, 1994; Gillberg, 1990; Tsai, 1998).
    In addition, children with autism may possess low levels of physical fitness (Auxter, Pyfer, & Huettig, 1997). This can be compounded by the fact that this population tends to have lower levels of interest or motivation to participate in games. Physical activity programs for children with autism may promote appropriate behaviors and improve cardiovascular endurance at the same time - two for one benefits. The purpose of this article is to discuss some instructional guidelines for developing activity programs in which children who are autistic (ages 5 to 8 years) can be motivated to participate in physical activities.

Instructional Guidelines for Providing Physical Activities
   
Teachers may have to overlook some inappropriate behaviors when initiating programs for children with autism for the sake of emphasizing increased access to physical activities. Initially, benefits gained from participating in physical activities may be more important than upsetting the child by trying to address behaviors (Berkeley & Zittel, 1998). As the child becomes acclimated to changes in routines required by initiating participation in a physical activity program, steps can be taken to address behaviors.
   Teachers using creative teaching techniques may be able to increase participation of children with autism. Changing activities frequently, employing learning stations, and planning transitions between stations may help overcome short attention spans. Care should be taken to address one sensory modality at a time, making certain a child's preferred sensory modality is targeted. Presenting more than one relevant stimulus at a time guarantees the child with autism will miss some part of a lesson. It is also important to understand the preferred sensory modality so as to develop individual lessons addressing that sensory mode.
   To help students attend to new skills while maintaining previously learned skills, the task variation method of teaching could be employed. This involves teaching new skills with maintenance tasks randomly interspersed and changed every two or three minutes. Use of task variations appeared to contribute to greater retention of previously learned materials (Weber & Thorpe, 1992). Station teaching is a useful application of this principle.
   An example of a program integrating physical activities for children with autism is Daily Life Therapy. This program, designed for children with autism, involves highly structured, group-oriented instruction (Quill, Gurry, & Larkin, 1989). In the Daily Life Therapy Program, vigorous physical activities are used to reduce stereotypical behaviors. Vigorous physical activities, in conjunction with appropriate behavior management practices (Lavay, French, & Henderson, 1997), can be helpful in reducing inappropriate behaviors in children with autism.

swimming picture
                                                                
Carol Huettig

                                                                                                                                                                                                              
Exercise Guidelines for a Physical Activity Program swimming picture                                                                Carol Huettig      
   
Any exercise program for children with autism should be developed with goals of not only enhancing overall physical activity, but also managing inappropriate behaviors such as stereotypical behaviors, outbursts, and pacing (see Figure 1, click here). Proper applications of exercise guidelines for children with autism facilitate program adherence and promote positive changes in physical activities (see Case Study, box below). For classroom teachers working with children having autism, it may be beneficial to consult with an adapted physical educator regarding developing programs, introducing physical activities, and instructing in use of any equipment (i.e., jump ropes, mini-trampolines, tricycles, bicycles, hippity-hops, heart rate monitors).
   Physical activities can include any rhythmic, large muscle activities that are continuous in nature (such as running, hopping, jumping, tricycling, cycling). Levels of activities and subsequent increases in performance are dependent on the initial fitness level of a child and his/her ability to adhere to the activity program. Examples of activities that may provide benefits to children with low fitness levels include walking/jogging, Going on a Bear Hunt, Going to the Zoo, Chasing Butterflies, Chasing my Shadow, Song about Slow and Fast, tricycling, cycling, Motor Speedway, and Going to the Circus.                                                                                                                                                                                                 
   If extraneous stimuli are not negative influences on performances and learning, there are several audiotapes that can add music to the activities, or be used as rewards for appropriate behaviors. Audiotapes available through most supply companies might include Preschool Aerobic Fun, containing sequenced activities to develop cardiovascular fitness; Fit As A Fiddle is an audiotape containing a series of exercises drawn from several disciplines, including dance, tumbling, and athletics.
   Videotapes can also be helpful for students with autism who can follow visual cues. Aerobikids is a motivational exercise tape designed for children. The 30-minute tape consists of a pre-warm-up, stretching, aerobics, and cool down activities. Fun Fit contains a variety of workout activities presented for children by Mary Lou Retton.
   In addition to music, children with autism may benefit from packaged aerobic activity sets. Fantastic Kids Fitness Program is an example of a packaged program that can provide cardiovascular fitness activities appropriate for children with autism. Activity cues provided in the set include 42 cards illustrating aerobic/strength movements using pictures, animals, and numbers.

 
 Case Study

   A child with autism was selected from a group of students receiving adapted physical education in a non-inclusive elementary school setting. The child (pseudonym of Nicholas) was overweight, displayed stereotypical behaviors (i.e., pacing, toe walking, hand flapping, rocking, echolalia) and was having difficulties remaining on task. In an interview with Nicholas' parents, it was discovered that he displayed substantially less stereotypical behavior after an afternoon of walking. For this reason, walking was selected as a primary method of intervention to improve Nicholas' behavior and maintain or increase his physical activity level.
   Nicholas was pre-tested to determine his cardiovascular fitness level. The test given required Nicholas to run/walk for 12-minutes on a 200-m walking track. He was required to stay within his age adjusted heart rate zone-as measured by a heart rate monitor. On the pretest he required 16 verbal and physical prompts, consisting of saying his name and touching his shoulder. Nicholas was then encouraged to participate in a physical activity program three days a week in small group settings (n = 3) for the academic year.
   The unit used by Nicholas to monitor exercise intensity consisted of a chest strap worn to monitor heart rate. Heart rate was displayed on a wrist unit. The wrist unit can be worn by the individual exercising for self-monitoring, or by a partner who stays within 4 ft of the student exercising to assist with maintaining exercise intensity. Initial duration of the walk was 15 minutes. Nicholas was provided verbal and physical prompts (a touch on the shoulder or upper back) to maintain intensity and on-task behavior.
   After 9 months Nicholas was post-tested to determine his fitness level. In this post-test, Nicholas increased distance walked in 12 minutes and decreased the number of prompts required to complete the walk from 16 to 6. In addition, while a causal relationship cannot be stated, Nicholas decreased the amount of stereotypical behavior displayed during and after his physical activity. A discussion with his teachers indicated he was not displaying as much stereotypical behavior in his classes following the walking program. Nicholas' parents indicated he had improved his behavior at home, as well, displaying a greater degree of concentration with fewer episodes of echolalia and stereotypical behaviors.

basketball activity picture

 

boy reaching graphic

"Any exercise program for children with autism should be developed with goals of not only enhancing overall physical activity, but also managing inappropriate behaviors..."



 

  Carol Huettig

 

   In conclusion, levels of physical activity and behaviors of children with autism may be positively impacted through participating in structured physical activity programs (see Figure 2, click here ). To enhance performances in this type of activity program requires incorporating meaningful physical fitness activities with traditional behavior management approaches. Relationships between physical fitness and behavior management have been supported by Kitahara (1984), and results of some research (Quill et al., 1989). Physical activity programs for children with autism may lead to a decrease in inappropriate behaviors, an increase in level of physical fitness, as well as greater enjoyment of physical activities and recreational times. Programs decreasing inappropriate behaviors and increasing physical fitness display the kind of two for one benefits that make participation advisable for children with autism.

Selected References
Allison, D.B., Basile, V. C., & MacDonald, R. B. (1991). Comparative effects of antecedent exercise and Lorazepam on the aggressive
       behavior of an autistic man. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disabilities, 21(1), 89-94.
American Psychiatric Association (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.).Washington, DC: Author.
Auxter, D., Pyfer, J., & Huettig, C. (1997). Principles and methods of adapted physical education and recreation (8th ed.). St. Louis:
      Mosby.
Berkeley, S., & Zittel, L. (1998). Teaching the child with autism in physical education. Achieving a Balance: Proceedings of the 6th
      National Conference on Adapted Physical Activity
. Western Illinois University: Macomb, IL.
Elliott, R. O., Dobbin, A. R., Rose, G. D., & Soper, H. V. (1994). Vigorous, aerobic exercise versus general motor training activities:
      Effects on maladaptive and stereotypic behaviors of adults with both autism and mental retardation. Journal of Autism and
      Developmental Disorders
, 24(5), 565-576.
Gillberg, C. (1990). Autism and pervasive developmental disorders. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 31(1), 99-119.
Huettig, C., & O'Connor, J. (1999). Wellness programming for young children with disabilities. Teaching Exceptional Children, 31(3),
      12-19.
Kitahara, K. (1984b) Daily life therapy (Vol. 3). Tokyo: Musashino Higashi Gakuen School.
Lavay, B. W., French, R., & Henderson, H. L. (1997). Positive behavior management strategies for physical educators. Champaign, IL:
       Human Kinetics.
Quill, K., Gurry, S., & Larkin, A. (1989). Daily life therapy: A Japanese model for educating children with autism. Journal of Autism and        Developmental Disorders,19(4), 625-635.
Rosenthal-Malek, A., & Mitchell, S. (1997). Brief report: The effects of exercise on the self-stimulating behaviors and positive responding
      of adolescents with autism. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 27(2), 193-202.
Tsai, L. T. (1998). Briefing paper: Pervasive developmental disorders. National Information Center for Children and Youth with
      Disabilities
, FS20, 1-16.
Weber, R. C., & Thorpe, J. (1992). Teaching children with autism through task variation in physical education. Exceptional Children,
      59(1), 77-86.


     John O'Connor is an assistant professor at Southern Illinois University Edwardsville in the Department of Kinesiology and Health Education. John has worked in public schools, clinical settings, and as a physical activity consultant with individuals with autism. Ron French is a professor at Texas Woman's University in Denton and is presently the director of two federally funded adapted physical education teacher preparation training programs. Hester L. Henderson is an associate professor in the Department of Exercise and Sport Science at the University of Utah. For the past 18 years she has served as director of the teacher training program in special physical education. She is project director of pre-service training grants at the bachelor's, master's, and doctoral levels.
   Cover Photo by Lisa Silliman-French



    

PALAESTRA dome